Poverty And Some Effects Of It That We Do Not Perhaps Think About As Carefully As We Should.

Recommended Posts

Methersgate
Posted
Posted (edited)

This leads me on to a point that has just been made to me - with some force - by She Who Must Be Obeyed, herself a rice farmer's daughter and the youngest of seven.

People are super-sensitive about poverty, and adding to it is a very widespread belief, in the Philippines, which is almost more like a Protestant belief than a Catholic one.

 

People believe that they are poor because it is THEIR FAULT.

In Protestant Europe and North America, of course, we believe, at the level of technical theology, in the doctrine of double predestination leading to God's Elect, or to put it more plainly we believe that God Helps Those Who Help Themselves, also called "PWE", the Protestant Work Ethic, as discovered by RH Tawney in "Religion and the Rise of Capitalism" and by Max Weber in "The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism".

That is not what the Catholic Filipino poor believe, though hey do work  mighty hard (just try ploughing with a carabao, or planting rice).

They believe that they are poor because God is punishing them because they are wicked people.

 

This belief is general.
 

This is why you may see the followers of "brother" Mike Velarde, in the El Shaddai movement, the Philippines' Catholic Church's deliberate answer to "charismatic" Protestant religions, taking out their empty wallets and holding them to the sky so that God may rain wealth into them.

This is why huge crowds follow the Black Nazarene, and similar devotional exercises.

If only they can stop being bad, God will forgive them and they will cease to be poor.   

You can see what a very useful belief this is, for those who are NOT POOR.
 

The thieving bastards in the Senate and in the House of Representatives are there because God has put them there so they must be good people and when they get away, with thieving and very often with murder this is not because the system is corrupt but because it is the Will of God.

Edited by Methersgate
  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Methersgate
Posted
Posted (edited)

What this means, of course, is that the burden of poverty is in effect doubled, by the Church itself.

 

To have to admit to being poor is to have to admit that you have done something pretty seriously wrong, and in a society where "face" really matters, that adds immensely to the burden already imposed on you and on your family by poverty.

 

The consequence is that people are desperately sensitive about it,

We need to be very, very careful how we handle this.

 

There is another aspect, too.

 

Since God made the poor the way they are, and he made the rich and powerful too, it follows that the rich and powerful, a group which includes ALL foreigners, were given the blessings they enjoy by God.

 

It follows that those blessings should be shared, since they are the result of luck not the result of hard work (and nobody sweating in a field thinks that sitting in an air conditioned office can be "work" of any sort!)

"You got it for free, so why can't I have some of it?" I'd gladly share my stuff with you, if I had any to spare like you do!"
 

Edited by Methersgate
  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Miguk
Posted
Posted

Very succinct summary.  I do feel their pain...I really do.  But my resources (foreigner thus assumed endless) really are finite and the need is infinite.  There has to be a line drawn somewhere.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jake
Posted
Posted

People believe that they are poor because it is THEIR FAULT.

That is not what the Catholic Filipino poor believe, though hey do work  mighty hard (just try ploughing with a carabao, or planting rice).

They believe that they are poor because God is punishing them because they are wicked people.

 

This belief is general.

 

This is why you may see the followers of "brother" Mike Velarde, in the El Shaddai movement, the Philippines' Catholic Church's deliberate answer to "charismatic" Protestant religions, taking out their empty wallets and holding them to the sky so that God may rain wealth into them.

This is why huge crowds follow the Black Nazarene, and similar devotional exercises.

If only they can stop being bad, God will forgive them and they will cease to be poor.   

You can see what a very useful belief this is, for those who are NOT POOR.

 

The thieving bastards in the Senate and in the House of Representatives are there because God has put them there so they must be good people and when they get away, with thieving and very often with murder this is not because the system is corrupt but because it is the Will of God.

Hello Andrew,

 

A wonderful essay of the plight of the poor Filipino and his family.  A very discreet vision that could only come

from actual and direct observation of the local social status.  The false prophets always have a lucrative and

deceitful business among the poor and blind sheeps.

 

Well done, my friend! 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

jon1
Posted
Posted
The false prophets always have a lucrative and deceitful business among the poor and blind sheeps.

 

Jake, that is because they are in the business of selling "hope". Without despair (poor, adversity, system against them getting ahead, church against birth control=more mouths to feed than resources can support, etc. etc.), there would be no need for "hope". The poor give what they really don't have to their masters who perpetually lead them into dire straits... 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jake
Posted
Posted (edited)

And all these sensitivities are right beneath the surface, and all the foreigner does is to say "It does not bother me" - it bothers THEM.

Yes, the head of the household is usually delighted to see a foreigner to see a foreigner paying court to his pretty daughter, but

he is also worried that the foreigner may just leave her "in the club" and disappear, and he also hates himself for having to hope

that that foreigner will give him money.

Hello Andrew,

 

Another great insight about the weak and the poor!  You are certainly a student of sociology, unique to the

Far Eastern region and their street level culture.  You got into the mind of the poor farmer, thinking about

what to do about his daughters when the whole family is starving.   

 

I wrote a piece a long time ago about my tears flowing freely when I witness this old and fragile Lola and her

niece making the rounds through the Olongapo bars.  The Lola would silently stand at a dark corner of the 

nightclub, while all the sailors and marines were whoopin' and hollerin' -- within 5 minutes of the floor show,

her niece was already naked, dancing to the tunes of Proud Mary (mid 70's).

 

That was their livelihood.  I immediately gave the Lola all my loose change (about 20 bucks) and ask them to

go home for the night.  Their thankful eyes of tears of joy......and I felt so ashamed.    

 

Fast forward to Mt Pinatubo's (1991) devastation of land and people of epic proportion.  Many of those young

daughters ended up in Angeles City.  It was a dark reality for farmers to contract out their little girls.  Again, it

was the matter of sheer survival, deep sacrifice and deeper shame.   

 

Is there a light at the end of their tunnel?  

 

Thank you for a good read, my friend.

Edited by Jake
reality check
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Paul_QLD
Posted
Posted

Thanks for that, a great summary and it may help me understand a little more of my girl's family history/life in the province and how she always says "we are poor, what to do?" when I ask her to try take some initiative to improve her/their life a little ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

stevewool
Posted
Posted

Its a funny world we live in, some say we are rich when we go over for the first time to find the one we want to be with the rest of our life,

Well we may have a little more then most, but its hard earned and its easily gone too, but what i have learned from my Ems is  yes i am richer in wealth then her and her family but they are way richer in kindness that i will ever be, its trying to get the happy medium between us, just my thoughts

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...